Death on the Nile (2022)
4/10
Starring
Kenneth Branagh
Tom Bateman
Annette Bening
Russell Brand
Ali Fazal
Dawn French
Gal Gadot
Directed by Kenneth Branagh
The
claustrophobic setting of Murder
on the Orient Express made it very appealing to see Poirot solve the
case in such tight circumstances. Kenneth Branagh’s adaptation
of the film in 2017 was a joyful ride, even though it felt a tad dull
at times. His portrayal of Poirot didn’t quite capture the magic of Albert
Finney or Peter
Ustinov in their respective adaptations. And while I believe both of
them outshine Branagh’s portrayal, none of the three compares to David Suchet,
who played Poirot to perfection for nearly two decades.
This
new take on another Agatha Christie masterpiece sees Branagh once again working
both in front of and behind the camera. Unfortunately, it shares many of the
same flaws as his first outing as Poirot.
There’s
something about this movie’s plot that frustrates me, especially in the way
Branagh chose to adapt it. The film is overladen with needless CGI that’s far
too obvious to ignore. Branagh also seemed determined to outsmart Christie by
adding unnecessary elements, as though he wanted to upstage her in her own
story. Christie’s genius lies in her ability to take complex plots and make
them easy to follow without unnecessary detours. Branagh did the opposite.
For
example, Christie’s book doesn’t delve into Poirot’s past, his time in the war,
or how he got his mustache. Nor does it feature the overly dramatized sexual
tension between two characters that Branagh decided to include. The scene by
the Egyptian statue, meant to highlight the passion between Linnet (Gal Gadot)
and Simon (Armie Hammer), felt forced and entirely unnecessary. It was a
needless addition that didn’t serve the plot.
The
original book and the previous two adaptations have a way of keeping you on
edge with their intricate details—twin guns, nail polish, jewelry theft,
blackmail, and murder all intertwining seamlessly. The story unfolds aboard a
luxury steamer cruising along the Nile, where Linnet and Simon are on their
honeymoon. Linnet, an heiress, had stolen Simon from her best friend
Jacqueline, leading to a hasty marriage and an attempt to escape Jacqueline’s
wrath.
The
murder occurs when Linnet is shot in the head. Everyone on board becomes a
suspect, as it turns out they all have a connection to Linnet and something to
gain from her death. The setup is so carefully crafted that even Poirot must
dig deep to uncover the killer—or killers.
While
I prefer the 1978
adaptation of Death on the Nile, the 2004 version from the ITV
series Poirot with David Suchet is unbeatable. Suchet’s performance as
Poirot is reason enough to watch it if you haven’t already.
This
film’s ensemble cast of A-list actors should have delivered stellar chemistry,
but instead, it felt disjointed. The central relationship—Linnet and Simon’s
romance—needed to anchor the plot, but Gal Gadot and Armie Hammer lacked any
real chemistry. Their union felt forced, with Gadot often looking like she’d
rather be anywhere else, a detail too glaring to ignore.
To
Branagh’s credit, some tweaks to the story were made to add diversity, which I
appreciated. However, the poor pacing and bloated runtime undermined the film’s
impact. By the halfway point, Linnet was still alive, and I found myself
impatiently waiting for someone to kill her already. The slow pacing and
unnecessarily long buildup made it a wonder I didn’t fall asleep.