You People (2023)
5/10
Starring
Jonah Hill
Lauren London
David Duchovny
Nia Long
Julia Louis-Dreyfus
Eddie Murphy
Directed by Kenya Barris
This is no disrespect—I love
Eddie Murphy. I’m a child of the ’80s, and I grew up on Eddie Murphy. That
said, I blame Seinfeld, Veep, and The New Adventures of Old
Christine because the one person I couldn’t wait to see was Julia
Louis-Dreyfus. That woman is comedy gold, and she was amazing in this movie for
me. So now that I’ve put it all out there, let me dive into the movie, You
People.
It had its moments where I
laughed, but overall, it’s average because it never quite got it right.
The cast alone must have set
Netflix back a lot, because this movie isn’t here to play. The plot, story, and
cast were cool up to a point, but then the movie took a path that boiled down
to silliness and just became creepy.
This movie is about Ezra (Jonah
Hill), a grown man from Jewish parents, who meets and falls in love with Amira,
a grown woman from Black Muslim parents. The couple are fine with each other,
and even Ezra’s parents welcome Amira with joy. But the stereotypical portrayal
of Black people rears its head when Amira’s parents are shown as not being so
down with the idea. At first, the way it was going seemed cool and funny, but
then the movie took a turn. When the parents meet, I didn’t like how the Black
family (or any family, for that matter) were portrayed as hostile jerks.
In reality, if a family doesn’t
approve, they probably wouldn’t show up at all, instead of showing up and
talking about a character’s anti-Semitic comments while proudly claiming to be
a follower of such ideas. Nobody does that—it’s just wrong.
I liked this movie until halfway
through, when everything fell apart. The families start comparing the Holocaust
to slavery (Jews and Blacks), and I couldn’t believe it. Who does that? Even if
someone did, why would anyone think I’d want to see that in a romantic comedy?
The movie crossed every line between a social experiment and a rom-com. It
would have been better if it fully committed to one genre—either comedy or
drama focused on social issues.
The movie drips with things we’ve
all seen before, borrowing ideas left and right. Still, after the first 10
minutes, I was sold. But then the families meet, and I wanted to return the
ticket.
One thing that almost made me
walk away before watching this was Kenya Barris. I haven’t liked much of his
work (Soul (2020) was good, though), so I had a feeling this movie
wouldn’t be for me—and I wasn’t wrong.
However, Julia Louis-Dreyfus was
heads and shoulders the best thing that happened to this movie.